LEARN A WORD A DAY
Showing posts with label Short Stories Form 4-5 (Old). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Short Stories Form 4-5 (Old). Show all posts

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

The Necklace: Questions & Answers

Give brief responses to these questions on ‘The Necklace’.

1 How does the author describe Mathilde? She was pretty, charming but unhappy
2 Why was Mathilde so unhappy? She believed she deserved better
3 Why Mathilde did not like to visit her former schoolmate at the convent? She felt sad when she went home.
4 What does this tell you about Mathilde? What kind of a person was she? She was envious and dreamy
5 Why was Mathilde not happy with the invitation to the ball? She had no dress to wear
6 What was Loisel keeping the 400 francs for? He wanted to buy a gun
7 Why was Mathilde not happy again as the ball drew near? She has no jewels to wear
8 Pick the phrases that show that Mathilde had a great time at the ball. ‘Great success’, ‘danced with rapture’, ‘passion’
9 How did Loisel and Mathilde manage to replace the necklace? They borrowed the money
10 How long did it take them to repay all their debts? It took them 10 years
11 What did Mathilde find out from Madame Forestier one day? Mathilde found out that they bought a real diamond necklace to replace the fake one
12 What were your feelings on finding out what had happened to Mathilde? I felt terribly sorry for Mathilde and Loisel (Accept any suitable answers)

Read the extract from the short story ‘The Necklace’ below and answer the question that follows, basing your answer on your knowledge of the whole story.

‘You say that you never noticed it, then! They were very similar.’
And she smiled with a joy that was at once proud and ingenuous. Madame Forestier, deeply moved, took her hands.
‘Oh, my poor Mathilde! Why, my necklace was paste! It was worth at most only five
hundred francs!’

Based on the information in the extract, briefly describe what happened in the above incident.
Mathilde had bought a diamond necklace for Madame Forestier, as Mathilde had lost the one she had borrowed. Now, after some years, Madame Forestier tells her that the necklace was only a fake.

Read the extract from the short story ‘The Necklace’ below and answer the question that follows, basing your answer on your knowledge of the whole story.

‘What’s the matter? What’s the matter?’ he asked.
By a violent effort she conquered her grief and replied in a calm voice, while she wiped away her tears, ‘Nothing Only I have no gown, and therefore, I can’t go to this ball Give your card to some colleague whose wife is better equipped than I am’

Based on the information in the extract, briefly describe what happened after the incident.
Her husband gives her the money to buy herself a gown.

Sunday, August 16, 2009

The Necklace: Exercise

Read the extract from the short story The Necklace and answer the questions that follow.

But one evening her husband had came home with a triumphant air and holding a large envelope in his hand.
“There,” said he, “there is something for you.”
She tore the paper quickly and drew out a printed card which bore these words:


The Minister of Public Instruction and Madame Georges Ramponneau request the honour of M. and Madamme Loisel’s company at the place of the Ministry on Monday evening, January 18th.



(a) i) When was the ball held ?

____________________________________________[1 mark]
ii) Who invited the Loisels?
____________________________________________[1 mark]
(b) Based on the extract above, what can you say about Mathilde when she tore the paper quickly?
_____________________________________________[1 mark]
(c) If you were Mathilde, what would your intention be by attending the ball?

_____________________________________________

_____________________________________________[2 marks ]

Saturday, August 1, 2009

The Necklace: More exercises

Exercise 1

1. Why didn’t Jeanne recognize Mathilde at first?
2. What was the life Mathilde lived in the past ten years like?
3. Why did Mathilde borrow a necklace from her friend?
4. Where was Pierre Loisel working?
5. Why had she been working very hard?

Exercise 2

1. How did Mathilde feel when her husband told her the good news?
2. Why was Mathilde worried?
3. How much did her dress cost her?
4. What else did she want to wear?
5. What did Pierre suggest?
6. What did they decide to do? Why?
7. When did Mathilde decide to see her friend?

Exercise 3

1. What kind of necklace did she get?
2. How did they enjoy the ball at the palace?
3. What happened on their way home after the ball?
4. What did they do for Jeanne?
5. How much did the diamond necklace cost?
6. What did they do in order to pay back the debt?

The Drover's Wife: Exercises

Exploring the text


1. Make a list of the personal qualities of this woman as they are presented to the reader in the extract (for example, courage, cunning).

2. Divide into small groups. Complete the table below in your group and place each of the qualities from individual lists into the most appropriate column.

Positive qualities

Negative qualities

As a class, share your responses – appoint a recorder to draw up the same table on the board. Record the responses of each group – place a tick next to each word when it is repeated.

As a whole class, discuss:

  • Are there more positive than negative qualities?
  • Has there been disagreement about the category in which a particular quality belongs? Which one/s? Why do you think this is the case?
  • What is the quality that you, as a class, think is the dominant one in this woman's personal make-up?
  • As a class, discuss and develop a definition of ‘personal qualities’.
3. Draw a symbol map of the five qualities that you think are the most significant in this woman's character. Choose a visual symbol to represent each of the qualities. For example:

4. Write out two copies of the following questions on slips of paper:

  • What are the elements of our lives which help to shape our ‘character’ and personal qualities?
  • Do you think that we, as Australians, share certain character qualities? What do you think these are?
  • What is Henry Lawson saying about the way the environment (that is, the bush) has shaped the character of the woman in this story?

Divide into six groups. Each group discusses a particular question. As groups, prepare answers to share with the rest of the class. All members of the group should be involved in the reporting back process.

5. Write your own short story set in present times about an incident that highlights a character's special personal qualities. The character is you.

Friday, July 31, 2009

The Drover's Wife: Character

How would you characterize the drover's wife?

The narrator describes the drover's wife as a "gaunt, sun-browned bushwoman." The story is set in the Outback of Australia, hence the term "bushwoman." Life in the bush is hard, so she has to be strong in body and will. When her son spots a snake, she doesn't panic; instead she makes a safe place for herself and her children until she knows the snake is gone. Although her husband has been away for 6 months, she isn't afraid or worried that he won't return. A drover's job takes him away for months at a time, and she's used to being alone. She must be educated because she reads the Young Ladies' Journal; we know she dreams of a different life because she enjoys looking at the fashions.

She has faced fires and floods and sickness and other problems all on her own, but the narrator says she seems to be content with her life:

She seems contented with her lot. She loves her children, but has no time to show it. She seems harsh to them. Her surroundings are not favourable to the development of the “womanly” or sentimental side of nature.


The Sound Machine: Short film

The Sound Machine: Exercises

1)Complete the story with the words from the box

The Sound Machine tells the story of Klausner’s ………………………………with sound. He makes a …………………that he thinks can hear flowers …………………when they are picked. He discovers this
when he claims he can listen to flowers screaming when his ………………………cuts them off. In order to confirm his idea, he tests the machine by cutting a tree with an axe and ………………………. the doctor to put ………………… on the cut. …………………….., he …………………………… his doctor to put iodine on the cut to ………………………….. the tree.

stitches-neighbour -persuades-cure-screaming-finally-machine-wants-obsession

2) Are these sentences true or false? Correct the false ones

a. Klausner has bought a machine to hear sounds that we cannot normally hear. …..
b. Klausner is a tall, strong man. …..
c. Klausner hears the flowers scream when they are cut. …..
d. He asks Mrs Saunders to cut another flower. …..
e. Klausner phones the doctor very late at night. …..

3) Write the questions for the following answers.

a. Because Klausner phones him.
b. Plants cry.
c. Because she is afraid of Klausner. She thinks he is acting crazy.
d. Because Klausner phones him again.
e. The branch makes a horrifying sound, as if it were crying.
f. Because he thinks Klausner is mad so agrees to use iodine.

4) ANSWER THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS

In the garden…

a) What does Klausner hear??
b) In his opinion, what is making the noise?
c) How does Klausner prove his idea?

In the park…

a) What does the doctor hear?
b) What does the doctor think?

Your opinion…

a)Do you think that plants can feel??
b)What would you do if you were the doctor?

Monday, July 27, 2009

The Necklace: Questions and answers

Question 1

Question: Was Mathilde happy as the wife of a clerk?
Answer: She was unhappy. She dreamt of riches and a luxurious life.

Question 2

Question: Why did she not visit her friend any more?
Answer: Her friend was very rich. She felt depressed when she returned to her home. So she avoided visiting her.

Question 3

Question: What did the large envelope contain?
Answer: An invitation to the palace of the Ministry on Monday evening.

Question 4

Question: Why was Mathilde unhappy even after receiving the invitation?
Answer: She was unhappy as she did not have an evening gown to wear to the palace.

Question 5

Question: How much money did she ask for the new gown?
Answer: She asked 400 francs for the new gown.

Question 6

Question: Though she had a new gown she still felt that something was missing. What was missing?
Answer: Though she had a new gown she still felt that something was missing. She wanted some jewellery to wear.

Question 7

Question: What did Loisel suggest in place of jewellery?
Answer: Loisel suggested a bunch of flowers in place of jewellery.

Question 8

Question: Why did Mathilde visit her friend?
Answer: Mathilde wondered if she could borrow a piece of jewellery from her friend.

Question 9

Question: What did Mathilde finally choose from her friend's jewel box?
Answer: Mathilde finally chose a sparkling diamond necklace from her friend's jewel box.

Question 10

Question: How did they reach home after the ball?
Answer: They walked for a short distance and then caught a cab home.

Question 11

Question: What did Mathilde suddenly discover after she returned home?
Answer: She wanted to look at herself once more in the mirror before retiring for the night. Then she saw that the necklace was missing. It had fallen off.

Question 12

Question: What did Madame Forestier not discover?
Answer: Madame Forestier had loaned a diamond necklace to Mathilde. Mathilde had lost the necklace, but bought a similar necklace. Madam Forestier did not discover that the necklace returned was not the one that Mathilde had borrowed.

Question 13

Question: What course of life did the Loisel's have after this incident on the fateful evening?
Answer: They had a very difficult life. Mathilde had to do all the house work, her husband worked in the evenings and worked late into the night copying manuscripts at five sous per page.

Question 14

Question: Explain the ironic end of the story.
Answer: Mathilde and her husband pay off a debt of 32,000 francs. But they realize at the end that the necklace had actually been a fake one costing only 500 francs.

Question 15

Question: What were the various wrong steps taken by Mathilde?
Answer:
1) To crave for a gown and jewel beyond their capacity
2) To borrow an expensive jewel
3) Not to inform her friend about the loss

Question 16

Question: Read the given extracts and write what they reveal about the various characters of the story.
Mathilde
a) She was born as if by slip of fate into 'a family of clerks'
b) She felt so sad when she came home
c) She threw the invitation on the table crossly.
d) Haven't you any more?
e) She bore her part with sudden heroism.
Answer:
a) She dreams of a rich life and dreams beyond her means
b) She was ashamed of her poverty
c) Ungrateful
d) Dissatisfied, wants to look extremely rich and beautiful
e) Is a strong woman deep down. Faces up to her wrong deed

Question 17

Question: Read the given extracts and write what they reveal about the various characters of the story.
The Husband
a) 'There' is something for you.
b) Very well I will give you 400 francs
c) Go and look up our friend Madame 'Forestier'
d) Wait a bit, you will catch cold outside
e) 'I shall go back on foot'
f) Late at night he often copied manuscripts
Answer:
a) Loving husband hoping to please his wife
b) Sacrifices his needs for those of his wife
c) Resourceful - thinks of a way out of the situation
d) Concerned about his wife
e) Action oriented person. Instead of merely shouting at Mathilde or scolding her, he goes in search of the necklace
f) Patiently pays off the most alarming debt

Question 18

Question: Discuss the various causes for the problems faced by the Liosels.
Answer: The Liosels were a happy couple. The husband was a clerk with a steady income and his wife Mathilde had a maid to help her with the shopping and the housework. But Mathilde dreamt of a rich social life.

One day they received an invitation to a ball at the palace by the Ministry. This was the beginning of their problems. Mathilde refused to attend the party without an elegant gown and jewel. The gown she bought for 400 francs but the jewel she borrowed. She could have accepted her husband's suggestion and worn flowers instead. She chose to borrow the jewel and unfortunately lost it.

Having lost it she was not brave enough to reveal it to her friend. She replaced the necklace with a similar one from the jewellers. Had she owned up to her friend she would have known that it only cost 500 francs.

But the contribution of all these factors led to their having to lead 10 years of miserable existence.

Question 19

Question: What do you think happened after Mathilde and her friend met?
Answer: There are many possible conclusions. Given below are three. You may choose one of these or any other logical conclusion that you can think of.

a) Madam Forestier sympathizes with Mathilde. Consoles her for some time. Then goes away not realizing the vast difference the incidents made to their life.

b) Madam Forestier is overcome with sorrow. She takes Mathilde home. Treats her well. Forces her to take back the diamond necklace. Mathilde and her husband begin life afresh with the money got by selling the necklace.

c) Madam Forestier consoles and sympathizes with Mathilde. Then she rushes home to see the diamond necklace again. Soon she remembers that two years ago she had gifted it away to one of her faithful maids who had to leave work for she got married'.

Question 20

Question: "But Madam'. I do not know -you must be mistaken" who says this and why? Do not exceed 75 words.
Answer: These words are spoken by Madame Forestier, when Madame Loisel meets her after a long period. Madame Loisel has become an ordinary woman after the replacement of the lost necklace. It has drawn life out of her. When she meets Madame Forestier, the latter doesn't recognize Madame Loisel because of the physical changes that she has undergone. She now looks hard, rough and very ordinary.

Question 21

Question: How did people react to Madame Loisel at the ball?
Answer: Madame Loisel was a great success at the ball. She was prettier than any other woman present there. All the men were greatly impressed by her beauty, grace and personality. She stood taller than all the other women at the party by her sheer elegance. All those present there, kept looking at her and they asked her, her name. They wanted to be introduced to her as they thought that she belonged to the upper class of society. All the attaches of the cabinet wanted to dance with her. She got a lot of attention from everyone.

Sunday, July 26, 2009

The Sound Machine: Questions

Exercise 1
Choose the best answer.

1. Klausner’s machine is useful fr
A. storing spare, coloured wires
B. measuring the growth of plants
C. making a dog whistle with a higher sound
D. listening to sounds inaudible to the human ear

2. Klausner asks Mrs. Saunders to cut another rose because
A. he wants to make sue that his machine can really detect the cry made by the rose being cut
B. he enjoys hearing the flowers scream
C. he likes to frighten her
D. he likes yellow roses

3. Why does Klausner ask Dr. Scott to join him in the park?
A. He has hurt his ears and needs a doctor.
B. He is too tired to carry the machine back by himself.
C. The tree told him it wanted some iodine.
D. He wants Dr. Scott to hear the sound made by the tree.

4. Dr. Scott decides to treat the injured tree with iodine because
A. Klausner insists that he does so
B. he is doing a special experiment on plants
C. he thinks the tree will look nice with a purple iodine patch
D. he is also a botanish with an interest in plant conservation

5. Why does Dr. Scott first visit Klausner?
A. He wants to see Klausner’s new radio.
B. He wants to check up on Klausner’s sore throat.
C. He wants to ask Klausner to join him for a walk.
D. He wants to help Klausner make the machine.

6. What happens to Klausner’s sound machine at the end of the story?
A. It is given to Dr. Scott for safekeeping.
B. It is smashed by the falling branch.
C. Klausner smashes it with his axe.
D. Klausner takes it home.

Exercise 2
Write short answers to the following questions.

1. What does the sound machine look like?

2. What does Mrs. Saunders think of Klausner when he tells her about her roses screaming in pain?

3. What does Klausner do to confirm his discovery about the sounds from the sound machine?

4. Briefly describe, in your own words, what Klausner hears when he swings his axe against the tree trunk the first time.

5. Why does the doctor paint the tree with iodine?

6. In your opinion, why does the branch fall?

The Drover's Wife: More Questions

Exercise 1
Choose the best answer.

1. When Tommy first sees the snake, what does he want to do?
A. He wants to hit the snake with a stick.
B. He wants to throw the stick at the dog.
C. He wants to throw his stick at the snake.
D. He wants to throw the snake into the wood-heap.

2. The drover's wife makes the children sleep on the table because
A. that is the cleanest place in the house.
B. that is the way they always sleep.
C. that is the only place with a candle.
D. that is the safest place in the house.

3. What does the brother-in-law do when he visits the drover's wife once a month?
A. He brings groceries for the family.
B. He takes the sheep to the market.
C. He catches the snakes in the house.
D. He takes the cow to the market.

4. Which statement best describes Alligator?
A. He loves to welcome the relatives when they visit.
B. He will probably be sold in the market one day.
C. He will probably be killed by a snake one day.
D. He is a black and white dog.

5. Which statement best describes Tommy?
A. He wants to be a drover like his father.
B. He is brave and wants to kill the snake.
C. He likes dogs that kill snakes.
D. He is very afraid of the snake.

Exercise 2
Write short answers to the following questions.

1. Why does the drover's wife set out two dishes of milk?

2. What does the drover's wife do when the thunderstorm comes?

3. What does the drover's wife do every Sunday?

4. Why did the husband stop being a farmer?

5. Briefly describe the drover's house.

6. Briefly describe Tommy's character.

7. Why does the drover's wife cry at the end of the story?

The Necklace: Questions

Exercise 1
Choose the correct answer.

1. Which statement best describes the Loisels’ marriage?
A. They are poor but loving and contented.
B. They are not well matched as they desire totally different things.
C. They are happy as they are able to save up for many luxuries.
D. They are well matched as Mathilde is a good cook who loves to make her husband’s favourite dishes.

2. Mathilde refuses to wait for a cab inside the building because
A. she wants to walk in the fresh air.
B. she can get a cab faster than Loisel.
C. she is afraid to be alone without Loisel.
D. she is ashamed to be seen in her modest wraps.

3. Loisel suggests that Mathilde ask Madame Forestier to lend her some jewellery because
A. Madame Forestier lends jewellery to everyone
B. Madame Forestier owes her a favour
C. Madame Forestier is her relative
D. Madame Forestier is her friend

4. Why does Mathilde write to Madame Forestier?
A. She wants to borrow the necklace.
B. She wants to invite her friend to tea.
C. She wants to thank her friend for the necklace.
D. She wants to have more time to look for the necklace.

5. What does ‘dressed like a woman of the people’ (p. 36) mean?
A. Dressed very stylishly
B. Dressed very fashionably
C. Dressed like a society lady
D. Dressed very plainly and cheaply

6. Madame Forestier appears so much younger than Mathilde at the end of the story because
A. she has a child to take care of
B. she has not had to work hard like Mathilde
C. she has had plastic surgery
D. she is wearing her best dress and the necklace

Exercise 2
Write short answers to the following questions.

1. What does Mathilde dream about at the beginning of the story?

2. Why does Mathilde want a new gown?

3. Why is Mathilde so happy at the ball?

4. Why is Loisel sleeping at the ball?

5. At the end of the story, what does Madame Forestier tell Mathilde about the necklace?

The Lotus Eater: Questions

Exercise 1
Choose the correct answer.

1. The narrator sees Wilson for the first time
A. in the Bay of Naples
B. on Mount Vesuvius
C. in a beautiful garden
D. on a hillside

2. Which of the following statements is true about Wilson's life on the island of Capri?
A. He often entertains friends in his cottage.
B. He supports himself by giving piano lessons.
C. He lives a quiet life all by himself.
D. He lives in the cottage with Assunta and her husband.

3. Wilson said he bought an annuity for twenty-five years. How did he get the money to do this?
A. He won a cash prize.
B. He inherited money from his family.
C. He made a very profitable business deal.
D. He had savings and he sold his house.

4. When Wilson's money first ran out
A. Assunta asked Wilson to leave
B. Assunta found Wilson a job as a boatman.
C. Assunta continued to clean and cook for Wilson.
D. Assunta sometimes asked the narrator's friend for some money for Wilson.

5. Why does the narrator's friend say that Wilson's mind was damaged by the smoke?
A. Because Wilson would not leave the hospital
B. Because Wilson did not recognize the narrator's friend
C. Because Wilson borrowed small sums of money
D. Because Wilson would not pay the rent

6. What was Wilson doing when the narrator saw him for the last time?
A. He was hiding behind a tree.
B. He was walking by the beach.
C. He was sleeping on the hillside.
D. He was looking after Assunta's goats.

Exercise 2
Answer the questions based on your knowledge of the whole story.

1. Who thinks Wilson lives a dull life?

2. Where did Wilson live before moving to the island of Capri?

3. What does Wilson like about the island of Capri?

4. How does Wilson try to kill himself?

5. Who discovers Wilson in the cottage after he tries to kill himself?

6. Where does Wilson live when he leaves the cottage?

7. Why does the friend think that Wilson's mind was damaged by the smoke?

8. Describe the night Wilson finally died.

Sunday, July 19, 2009

The Necklace: Questions for discussion/writing

Copyright © 1989 Balance Publishing Company. All rights reserved.
  1. What is the setting of the story? [The setting is in the late 19th century, in Paris, France.]
  2. What evidence do you find in the story that tells you this? [The names are French. Paris is named as the city. The Champs-Elysees is a famous section in Paris, France. The Seine is a river in France that flows through Paris. Madame, is a French word. The currency used is the franc.]
  3. Before the party, how would you describe Mr. And Mrs Loisel's financial position? Are they poor, middle income or rich? How do you know? [They are middle income. They don't have expensive clothing, a big bank account, etc., but they have enough to live on and apparently live in a middle income part of town--after Marsha loses the necklace, they move to "a less favorable side of town."]
  4. Is Mr. Loisel more accepting of his financial/social place in life than Mathilde? [Yes. He obtains the invitation primarily for her. Also, it isn't so important to him that they have expensive things. For instance, he suggests she wear flowers rather than jewelry.]
  5. Is Madame Forestier the type of person who would have been cruel to Marsha about losing the necklace? [No. She seems to be very kind and generous.]
  6. How would you describe Mr. Loisel's character? [He is a wimp. He lets the people around him dominant him.] What evidence do you find in the play that supports this? [When he gives his wife the invitation, she is not happy with it; he seems to be hurt but says nothing about it. His wife has her way in everything--first there is the money to buy a new dress, then he encourages her to borrow expensive jewelry, and finally he goes deeply into debt to buy a replacement for the lost necklace. Even though he knows these things are not wise, he goes along with her and purchases the necklace.]
  7. What two choices do the Loisels have when they realize the necklace is permanently lost? [They could tell Madame Forestier about losing the necklace and make arrangements to pay for it, OR they could do what they did--buy a new one and replace it.]
  8. Mathilde has changed in many ways by the end of the story. In what ways has she changed? [By the end of the story, she is no longer young and beautiful. She has the appearance of someone who has spent many years under both physical and emotional stress. She appears to be less concerned about appearances, because in the end she tells Madame Forestier about losing the necklace.]
  9. It is obvious that Mathilde is unhappy at the beginning of the story. Does her husband understand her unhappiness? [He probably understands her to a degree, because he does several things to try to make her happy. For instance: He brings the invitation home for her. He allows her to buy a nice dress. He helps her decide where she can get jewelry. He goes along with her wishes to replace the lost necklace.]
  10. At the end of the story we find out that the original necklace was made of phony diamonds. What do you thinkMathilde's reaction would have been had Jeanne told her this fact when she borrowed the necklace? [Mathilde would not have wanted to borrow the necklace. She would probably have picked something more expensive, even though it might not have been as beautiful.]
  11. When she loaned Mathilde the necklace, why didn't Madame Forestier tell her friend that it wasn't valuable? [She probably knew Mathilde well enough to know that it was very important for her to save face. She probably thought it would embarrass her friend, if she told Mathilde the necklace she wanted to borrow was made of phony diamonds.]
  12. In a story, the conflict often arises between two characters, usually the protagonist and the antagonist. If Mathilde is the protagonist, who is the antagonist? [Mathilde herself is the antagonist. She has such a strong desire for the "good life" that she cannot bring herself to tell her friend that she lost her necklace. By refusing to tell the truth about losing the necklace, Mathilde creates a situation which, in the end, is her undoing. All of Mathilde's problems might have been avoided, had she told Madame Forestier the truth.]
  13. When Mr. And Mrs. Loisel are about to leave the jewelry store, the jeweler says, "You will have a lifetime to enjoy these diamonds." This statement as an example of Irony. Explain the irony of this statement. [In making the statement, the jeweler means the beauty of the necklace will be hers to enjoy; butthe Loisels and the reader know that far from being a pleasure, the diamonds are likely to give her a lifetime of work and hardship-the opposite of the implied meaning of the statement.]
  14. What is the symbolic meaning of the paste necklace as it relates to Mathilde at the beginning of the story? [The necklace symbolizes the glittering world that Mathilde is not a part of but desperately wishes to be.]
  15. When the true value of the lost necklace is revealed, it is obvious that Madame Forestier owes Mathilde a great deal of money. Considering Madame Forestier's kind and generous nature, one could easily imagine her giving Mathilde the money. Mathilde could then afford to move in fashionable social circles and buy fashionable clothes of her own. Explain the irony of this. [Mathilde is no longer young and beautiful; she would look out of place fashionably dressed. If Mathilde should receive the money, the irony would be: Now that she can have beautiful things, Mathilde has no need for them.]
  16. What is the theme of "The Necklace"? [It is better to tell the truth and face the consequences than to try to protect one's pride by telling a lie.]

Additional Discussion/Writing Questions

ENVY

  1. How would you define the word envy?
  2. How was Mathilde envious?
  3. How can envy be harmful to oneself or others?
  4. Have you ever experienced envy?

TRUTH

  1. Have you ever had a personal experience where you found it hard to tell the truth, or where telling a lie seemed the right thing to do?
  2. Is it hard to always be truthful?
  3. Why is it important to be truthful?
  4. How would Mathilde's life have been different if she had been truthful?
  5. What advantages does telling the truth have over telling a lie?

CONTENTMENT

  1. How would you define "being content with your life"?
  2. How would you define "being discontented with your life"?
  3. Can discontent have a positive effect upon one's life? Explain.

BORROWING AND LENDING

  1. What responsibilities do you have when you borrow something?
  2. What responsibilities do you have when you lend something?
  3. How do you feel when you owe someone money and are overdue in repaying it?
  4. How do you feel when someone owes you money and is overdue in repaying it?

The Necklace: Summary

"The Necklace" by Guy de Maupassant starts with a description of a young woman, Mrs. Matilda Loisel. She is pretty and charming, but unfortunately she was born into a family of clerks. Because of her family's middle class stature, she has no hopes of becoming rich, famous or distinguished. Therefore, she agrees to marry a clerk in the Board of Education.

Matilda's modest life style makes her miserable. She suffers constantly because she feels that she should have been born into luxury. Everything about her surroundings depresses her, including her furniture and faded linens. Most women of her social stature would not even notice the things she sees as great flaws when surveying her apartment. She thinks about luxurious antechambers, with Oriental tapestries, bronze torches and servants who are made sleepy by decadent heating systems. Matilda longs for expensive bric-a-brac and ornate little rooms where ladies receive attention from well-known, wealthy men.

Her husband seems happy with the very things that depress her, including their meager meals. While she looks at the dirty tablecloth on the dining table, her husband exclaims with joy over simple pleasures and meager meals. She, meanwhile, thinks of all of the gourmet dinners in opulent rooms that she is missing.

"She had neither frocks nor jewels, nothing. And she loved only those things. She felt that she was made for them. She had such a desire to please, to be sought after, to be clever, and courted."

Her pain is so great that she cannot visit a rich friend because, upon returning home, she would cry for days over the despair of not having the things she desires.

One night, her husband comes home elated. He has an invitation in his hand for a party at the house of the Minster of Public Instruction. Instead of being happy, she is angry and spiteful, asking what she is supposed to do with it. Her husband says he thought it would make her happy. He went to great lengths to secure the invitation and promises she will see very important people at the event. She tells him she has nothing to wear. When he suggests that she wears the dress she dons when they attend the theater, she weeps. She says that she has no appropriate dress and that he should give the invitation to a colleague whose wife has a better wardrobe.

Matilda's husband asks what it would cost to buy a suitable dress. She decides that it would take about four hundred francs. He is dismayed because that is the exact amount he has saved to buy a gun. He had been hopping to join some hunting parties during the upcoming summer. Nevertheless, he agrees to give her the money.

It is now closer to the day of the ball. Matilda is sad, even though her dress is nearly ready. Her husband asks what is wrong, and she says she does not want to go the ball because she does not have jewelry to wear. He suggests wearing a few flowers, which look chic that season. She refuses, saying, "There is nothing more humiliating than to have a shabby air in the midst of rich women."

Her husband is pleased to come up with a solution to her problem. He suggests she goes to her friend, Mrs. Forestier, to ask her to lend Matilda some jewels. Matilda is thrilled by the suggestion. The next day, she goes to Mrs. Forestier's house and explains the situation. The woman gives her a jewelry case to look through and tells her to pick whatever she likes. At first, she sees some fine jewelry, but nothing seems just right. She asks Mrs. Forestier if she has anything else. Mrs. Forestier tells Matilda to look and see, because she is not sure what Matilda is looking for. Suddenly, Matilda discovers a superb diamond necklace. Her heart beats faster just looking at it. She is blissfully happy. She asks Mrs. Forestier if she can borrow the necklace. When the woman agrees, Matilda is overjoyed and embraces her with passion.

The night of the ball, "Madame" Loisel is a great success. She is the most beautiful, elegant, and joyful woman at the party. All of the men notice her and want to meet her. Even the Minister of Education pays attention to her. For that one night, she is happier than she has ever been.

She goes home at four o'clock in the morning. Her husband has been ready to go since midnight and has been half-asleep in a little salon with three other men whose wives were having a good time. They prepare to leave, but her modest coat embarrasses her. Her husband tells her to wait inside while he finds a cab, but she runs outside because she does not want the women wearing furs to see her everyday coat.

They do not find a cab and must walk in the cold for a while. They finally find a ride to their home. They walk wearily into their apartment. Her night is over, and he must be at the office in just a few hours. In a moment of horror, she realizes the necklace is no longer around her neck. Her husband retraces their steps. At seven o'clock, he returns empty-handed. The next morning, he goes to the police and cab offices and advertises in the newspapers, but the necklace does not turn up. He tells Matilda to write to Mrs. Forestier and tell her that she has broken the clasp on the necklace and must have it repaired. They hope it will buy them some time.

However, at the end of the week, the necklace is still missing. Mr. Loisel says that they must replace the jewelry. They go from jeweler to jeweler, looking for a necklace like the one Matilda lost. Finally, they find one that looks right. Even at a discount, it will cost them thirty-six thousand francs. Loisel only has eighteen thousand francs he inherited from his father. He borrows the rest from multiple sources, risking his whole future without knowing if he can ever repay the enormous debt. Matilda returns the necklace to Mrs. Forestier, who is angry that she did not get it back sooner.

Matilda now learns what it is like to live in real poverty. The couple gets rid of the maid and moves into smaller, attic rooms. Matilda must work endlessly doing even the most menial chores she once paid others to perform. Her husband works evenings doing copying and accounting. This miserable poverty lasts for ten years until they can repay the loans.

Now Mrs. Loisel seems old and weathered. She is no longer beautiful. Her hair, skin and nails are wrecked. However, sometimes when her husband is at work, she sits in the window and remembers that wonderful night when she was pretty and sought after. She thinks how her life would have been different if she had not lost the necklace.

One Sunday, while taking a walk, Matilda sees Mrs. Forestier. The woman is still young and pretty. Matilda says hello, but at first, her friend does not recognize the rough woman in front of her. When Matilda reveals her identity, Mrs. Forestier is astonished. Matilda tells Mrs. Forestier the truth about the necklace. She says it was very difficult, but the debt is repaid and she is now content with her life. She is pleased Mrs. Forestier never noticed the diamonds had been switched.

Mrs. Forestier is shocked and takes her hands. She tells Matilda that the diamond necklace she borrowed was fake and not worth more than five hundred francs.

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

The Necklace - Sample Questions

“What do you mean? You brought it back.”

“I brought you back another exactly like it. And it has taken us 10 years to pay for it. You can understand that it was not easy for us, who had nothing. At last, it is ended and I am very glad.”

Madame Forrestier had stopped.

“You say that you bought a necklace of diamonds to replace mine?”

“Yes. You never noticed it then! They were very similar.”

Answer the given questions below.

a. How long did it take the Loisels to settle their debts? (1 mark)

b. How did Mathilde feel after having settled the debts? (1 mark)

c. Why didn’t Madame Forrestier notice that the necklace given to her was a diamond necklace? (1 mark)

d. If you were Mathilde, what would you have done when you discovered that the lost necklace was worth only 500 francs? Give a reason for your answer. (2 marks)

Monday, June 22, 2009

The Drover's Wife: Questions

1. Who are the characters in this short story?
2. What is the main character like? How does the author tell us about her? Find words, expressions or passages in the text to illustrate this.
3. Do any of the characters change during the course of the story? If so, who, how and why?
4. List all the characters. What role do the minor characters play? What relationships are there between the characters? Do these change?
5. What is the plot of the story? How is the plot organized? How does the author build suspense?
6. What is the setting of the story? How important is the setting? How is the setting described? Find words, expressions or passages to illustrate this.
7. What is the theme of the story? What conflict or conflicts do you see? Are conflicts resolved? If so, how?
8. What is the point of view of this text?

Writing:
1. Write a portrait of the main character in “The Drover's Wife”. Back up your description with references to the text.
2. Write an analysis of the short story.

The Necklace


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Collection of SPM English Language Question Papers

2005
Terengganu Trial [Paper 1]

2007
Johor Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2], Terengganu Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2], Pahang Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2] [Answers], Melaka Trial 2007 [Paper 1] [Paper 2], TIMES [Paper 1] [Paper 2] SPB [Paper 1] [Paper 2]

2008

Terengganu Mid Year [Paper 1] [Paper 2],
Trial
MRSM Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2], SBP Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2], Kelantan Trial [Paper 1 & 2], Terengganu Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2], Kedah Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2], Pahang Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2], Johor Trial [Paper 1 & 2], Perlis Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2], Sabah Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2], Sarawak Trial [Paper 1 & 2], Melaka Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2]

2009

Terengganu TOV [Paper 1] [Paper 2] Terengganu Mid Year [Paper 1] [Paper 2]
Melaka Trial , Johor Trial , Sabah Trial , Kedah Trial , Perlis Trial , Times , SBP , Pahang Trial [Paper 1] [Paper 2]